Is an IVA better than bankruptcy?

Is an Individual Voluntary Arrangement (IVA) better than bankruptcy? The only real answer is "sometimes", as it depends on the individual in question: not just how much they owe, but a whole range of other factors, such as what they earn, what they own, whether or not they work, what kind of job they have if they do...

However, if you`re facing significant debts and wondering whether you`d be better off with an IVA or with bankruptcy, a debt specialist should be able to answer the really important question: "Is an IVA better than bankruptcy for me?"

Is an IVA better than bankruptcy for me?

It depends on your situation.

If:

• you are a tenant, and/or
• you have a low or unreliable income, and/or
• you are approaching retirement age,

...then bankruptcy might be better for you than an IVA.

On the other hand, if you have a reliable, reasonably high income and:

• you are a homeowner, and/or
• you hold a certain job (company director, for example),

...then an IVA might be better for you than bankruptcy.

Bankruptcy & IVA – the similarities

Bankruptcies and IVAs are both kinds of insolvency. They both allow borrowers to repay a portion of their unsecured debt and write off the remainder. They both limit individuals` ability to borrow while they`re in progress, and will affect their credit rating, which could make it harder and more expensive to obtain credit for the next 6 years (from the day they start). And finally, they`re both unable to write off certain kinds of debt (such as secured debts and court fines).

Bankruptcy & IVA – the differences

• IVA - Duration: Normally 5 years.
• IVA - Effect on career: No fixed rules, but some companies may not employ someone with an IVA.
• IVA - Effect on home: Highly unlikely to force the sale of your home, but will probably require the release of some equity in the fifth year of the IVA.
• IVA - Publicity: Will not be advertised, but will appear in the publicly available Individual Insolvency Register.

• Bankruptcy - Duration: Will last 1 year in most cases, but payments can last for 3 years and a BRO (Bankruptcy Restriction Order) can last 15 years (although this would only be granted in exceptional cases).
• Bankruptcy - Effect on career: You would not be allowed to hold certain positions, such as company director, local government councillor or school governor.
• Bankruptcy - Effect on home: Very likely to force you to sell your home.
• Bankruptcy - Publicity: Will be advertised in newspapers.

Bankruptcy or IVA – how do I know which is better for me?

It`s a complicated question, and this page only provides a brief overview of the issues involved. The choice you make will probably have a serious impact on your life for (at least) the next 6 years, so you should talk to a professional debt adviser before you make your decision.

For free advice, call Think Money on freephone 0800 195 2911.

Tags: iva, bankruptcy, debt, best, better than, which is best

Fees payable when continuing service is provided. Repaying debt over a longer period may increase the total amount to be repaid. Calls are recorded and are usually free from UK landlines. Mobile phone users may be charged and should check with their service provider.